Law Society of Saskatchewan
Find Legal AssistanceMember ProfileMember ResourcesContact
  • 0
    Cart
  • My Account
  • About Us
      • Latest News
      • Save the Date: Saskatchewan Access to Justice Week (October 23-27)
      • National Day for Truth and Reconciliation and Orange Shirt Day
      • Free Webinar! Enforcing Support Orders – October 26, 2023
      • News
        • Legal Sourcery
        • Podcast
        • ReSource
        • Videos
        • Benchers’ Digest
        • Case Mail
      • Mission and Values
      • Committees and Task Forces
      • Convocation
      • Benchers
        • Bencher Election 2018
        • Bencher Election 2021
      • Annual and Financial Reports
      • Contact Us
  • Initiatives
    • Initiatives
      The Law Society is seeking to identify legal service providers for new initiatives. This unique approach, the first of its kind in Canada, enables the Law Society to expand access to appropriately regulated legal services in a responsible and sustainable manner. The overall goal is to balance the need for enhanced access to legal services for underserved Saskatchewan citizens while ensuring public protection. For more information, click below. Consultation
      • Access to Justice
        • Future of Legal Services Initiative
          • The Limited Licensing Pilot
        • Limited Scope Legal Services – Information for the Public
        • Limited Scope Legal Services – Information for Lawyers
        • Saskatchewan Access to Justice Week
      • Equity, Diversity and Inclusion
        • Equity Office
      • Legal Information
        • Legal Information Guidelines
        • Saskatchewan Access to Legal Information
      • Innovating Regulation
      • Truth and Reconciliation
        • Additional Resources
        • Notice to Day School Survivors
      • Saskatchewan Justicia Project
  • Regulation
    • Remote Executing Of Certain Documents And Remote Witnessing Of Wills By Electronic Means Legislation Now Permanent
      We are happy to announce that today, the Government of Saskatchewan repealed the temporary emergency regulations related to remote execution of certain documents and wills and replaced those regulations with permanent regulations allowing for remote execution of documents via electronic means (i.e. video calls) to continue long-term beyond the end of the public emergency period. Practice Directives
      • Definition of the Practice of Law and Unauthorized Practice of Law
      • Firm Regulation
        • Designated Representative (DR) Hub
      • Act, Code and Rules
        • The Legal Profession Act, 1990
        • Code of Professional Conduct and Amendments
        • Law Society Rules, Amendments and Practice Directives
        • Rules Concordance – Read More
      • Hearings, Decisions and Rulings
        • Hearing Committee Adjudicator Roster
        • Pending Discipline Matters
        • Discipline Decisions
        • Conduct Review Database
        • Ethics Rulings Database
        • Pending Admissions and Education Matters
        • Admissions and Education Decisions
        • Disqualification and Reinstatement
      • Lawyers with Practice Conditions/Restrictions
      • Lawyer Trusteeships and Successors
      • Potential Complaint Outcomes
        • Ethics Committee
        • Competency Committee
        • Conduct Investigation Committee
  • Public
    • New Law Society Complaint Form
      The goal is to assist and encourage complainants to provide clear and concise descriptions of their concerns, and reduce confusion by removing technical terms that may not be fully understood by members of the general public (i.e.: “conflict of interest”). Complaint Form
      • Finding Legal Assistance
      • Find Legal Assistance Search Guidance
      • Get Legal Information, Resources, and Options for Assistance
      • What to Expect From Your Lawyer
      • Looking For Lost Wills
      • Making a Complaint
        • Complaints Process
      • Common Client Concerns
        • Understanding Lawyers’ Fees
        • Quality of Service
        • Conflict of Interest
        • Confidentiality
        • Withdrawal
        • File Transfers
      • Common Client Concerns
        • Role of an Estate’s Lawyer
        • Role of Opposing Lawyer
        • Breach of Trust Conditions/Undertakings
        • Lawyer’s Conduct in Court
        • Lawyer’s Outside Interests
  • Lawyers and Students
    • Career and Volunteer Opportunities
      • Becoming a Lawyer in Saskatchewan
        • Students-at-law
        • Transfer Lawyers
        • International Applicants
      • Becoming a Principal
      • Career And Volunteer Opportunities
        • Students Seeking Articles
      • Membership Services
        • Member Renewal Hub
      • Awards, Bursaries, Scholarships
      • Consultation
      • Locum Registry
      • Expanded Practice Advisor Program
      • Forms and Fees
        • Law Society Forms
        • Trust Account Forms
      • Western Conveyancing Protocol
        • Protocol for Saskatchewan
      • Practice Resources
        • General Resources
        • Successor Listing
        • King’s Bench Rules
      • Health and Wellness
      • Pro Bono Legal Services
  • Legal Resources
  • CPD
    • Continuing Professional Development
      • CPD Activities
        • CPD Calendar of Activities
        • CPD On Demand (Subscription)
        • CPD Activity Application Form
        • Recorded Versions Shop
        • Study Group Resources
      • CPD Policy
        • Reporting CPD Hours
        • Eligible CPD Activities
        • Approved Providers
        • Remedial CPD Plan Information
        • FAQs
        • Transition to One-Year CPD Term
      • Contact Us
      • Volunteers
      • Presenter Section
  • Shop
Law Society of Saskatchewan Saskatchewan Law Review Articles Catching the Middleman: Amendments to Money Laundering Provisions of the Criminal Code

The information provided on this blog is to, the best of our knowledge, accurate and up-to-date as of the date of posting. However, please be aware that information can change rapidly and without notice. Therefore, we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information presented after the posting date. It is advised that readers exercise due diligence and independently verify the accuracy of information they find on this blog news feed. Here are links to the most current information available in relation to our Membership, Saskatchewan Case Law, and Saskatchewan Legislation.

Catching the Middleman: Amendments to Money Laundering Provisions of the Criminal Code

June 28, 2021

From Saskatchewan Law Review 

Gabriel Simons*

 

SUMMARY

A recent Criminal Code amendment may drastically change how money laundering will be investigated and prosecuted in Canada. Now, when concealing or converting funds, rather than being required to know the property in question is the proceeds of crime, one only needs to be reckless as to the origin of the property to be found guilty of money laundering. This opens up the possibility that countless financial intermediaries—including lawyers, accountants, and bankers—may be prosecuted.

 

I. INTRODUCTION

The Canadian federal government has been largely ineffective at combatting money laundering in Canada.[1] increased scrutiny for its inaction and inability to effectively police money laundering,[2] in June 2019 the federal government amended s. 462.31(1) of the Criminal Code.[3] Prior to this amendment, and since s. 462.31(1)’s inception in 1989,[4] in order to be found guilty of the offence of money laundering one must have intended to conceal or convert property from an illegitimate form into a legitimate form with the knowledge that the converted property was the proceeds of crime. The June 2019 amendments changed the mens rea of the offence of money laundering from one requiring intent to one that may also be found in instances of recklessness.[5] This particular amendment is impactful because it dramatically increases the scope of actors who can be prosecuted for money laundering—including lawyers.

 

II. PRIOR ATTEMPTS TO PREVENT MONEY LAUNDERING IN CANADA

Although Canada’s fight against money laundering has been described as being “in its infancy,”[6] there is a prolonged history of the federal government attempting to involve legal professionals in the battle against money laundering.[7] Recent amendments to the rules governing lawyers by Canadian law societies are the result of conciliatory efforts with the federal government to quell concerns of criminals using the legal profession as a vehicle for money laundering.[8] Even so, the legal profession is still described as a “‘black hole’” for financial crimes.[9] Specifically, the rules surrounding lawyers’ professional responsibilities have stayed entirely within the control of the legal profession, and it remains difficult for those outside of the profession to determine the origin of client funds.[10] This generally leads to dead ends in financial crime investigations and exacerbates Canada’s money laundering problem.[11] These concerns contributed to the most recent attempt by the federal government to expand its ability to prosecute and track money laundering.

 

III. THE EFFECT OF THE JUNE 2019 AMENDMENT

The June 2019 amendment to the Criminal Code is intended to catch the intermediaries of the money laundering business. For this discussion, it is essential to analyze the full wording of the amended provision, s. 462.31(1), of the Criminal Code:

Every one commits an offence who uses, transfers the possession of, sends or delivers to any person or place, transports, transmits, alters, disposes of or otherwise deals with, in any manner and by any means, any property or any proceeds of any property with intent to conceal or convert that property or those proceeds, knowing or believing that, or being reckless as to whether, all or a part of that property or of those proceeds was obtained or derived directly or indirectly as a result of

(a) the commission in Canada of a designated offence; or

(b) an act or omission anywhere that, if it had occurred in Canada, would have constituted a designated offence.[12]

As can be seen, the wording of this offence is broad. The plain meaning of the provision suggests that any interaction with funds that are the proceeds of a designated offence,[13] where an individual intends to convert the funds and is reckless as to the source of those funds, could now result in a conviction for money laundering. The guilty party does not have to intend to convert the proceeds of crime; they need only intend to convert the property in question and be reckless as to the source of that property. Before the amendment, the scope of the provision was restricted by the required mens rea of intent, which prevented those unwittingly involved in laundering money from being prosecuted. Now, both the actus reus and the mens rea of the offence are broad and wide-reaching. A banker converting Canadian currency into a foreign currency without first establishing a legitimate source of the funds, a lawyer placing money in trust for a client, an accountant transferring ownership of a business, and countless other daily financial transactions are now at risk of being considered money laundering offences.

Given past difficulties surrounding the prosecution of money laundering in Canada,[14] there may be arguments suggesting that increasing the pool of potentially guilty parties is necessary to reduce the total amount of funds laundered through Canada’s financial system. The amendment may lead to increased scrutiny of large financial transactions across the Canadian financial industry, in turn making it more difficult for criminals to take advantage of unwitting agents to launder their money. However, the amendment also greatly increases the potential penalty for those who are taken advantage of by criminals. With these new amendments, lawyers, for instance, who fail to take the proper steps when determining the source of a client’s funds will now not only face possible professional sanction from their law society, but also a prison sentence of up to ten years.[15]

 

IV. CONCLUSION

The amendments to s. 462.31(1) of the Criminal Code take an already broad (yet historically ineffective) provision and give it an even broader scope. The lowering of the required mens rea not only targets those attempting to launder money, but also targets those who may be unknowingly involved in a money laundering scheme. It remains to be seen if this amendment will effectively increase the scrutiny of financial transactions or prosecution of those attempting to launder money. Nonetheless, the risk of prosecution for countless professionals involved in everyday financial transactions has markedly increased while the risk for those attempting to launder money remains largely the same.

*           JD Candidate (Saskatchewan).

[1]           See generally Dirty Money: An Independent Review of Money Laundering in Lower Mainland Casinos conducted for the Attorney General of British Columbia, by Peter M German (Victoria: AGBC, 31 March 2018), online (pdf): <news.gov.bc.ca/files/German_Gaming_Final_Report.pdf>, archived: <perma.cc/B8F9-ABKA> [German Report Part 1]; Expert Panel on Money Laundering in BC Real Estate, Combatting Money Laundering in BC Real Estate, (Victoria: Minister of Finance, 2019) at 13–15, online (pdf): <www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/housing-and-tenancy/real-estate-in-bc/combatting-money-laundering-report.pdf>, archived <perma.cc/H4QH-8NKT>; Kevin Comeau, “Why Canada’s money-laundering problem is far bigger than we think”, Financial Post (28 May 2019), online: <business.financialpost.com/opinion/why-canadas-money-laundering-problem-is-far-bigger-than-we-think>, archived: <perma.cc/MVA2-KD4W>.

[2]           Department of Finance, News Release, “Government of Canada Leads National Response to Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing” (13 June 2019) online: Government of Canada <www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2019/06/government-of-canada-leads-national-response-to-money-laundering-and-terrorist-financing.html>, archived: <https://perma.cc/9QNK-G2CZ>.

[3]           RSC 1985, c C-46 [Criminal Code].

[4]           German Report Part 1, supra note 1 at para 13.

[5]           Criminal Code, supra note 3, s 462.31(1).

[6]           José Hernandez, “Money laundering is a national crisis. What now?”, Pivot Magazine (7 March 2019), online: CPA Canada <www.cpacanada.ca/en/news/pivot-magazine/2019-07-03-jose-hernandez-money-laundering>, archived: <perma.cc/CWJ8-T862>.

[7]           See e.g. Canada (Attorney General) v Federation of Law Societies of Canada, 2015 SCC 7, [2015] 1 SCR 401; Amy Salyzyn, “A False Start in Constitutionalizing Lawyer Loyalty in Canada (Attorney General) v. Federation of Law Societies of Canada” (2016) 76 SCLR 169.

[8]          See e.g. Federation of Law Societies of Canada, Federation News, “Federation welcomes opportunity to work with federal government to address issues related to money laundering and terrorist financing” (13 June 2019), online: FLSC <flsc.ca/federation-welcomes-opportunity-to-work-with-federal-government-to-address-issues-related-to-money-laundering-and-terrorist-financing>, archived: <perma.cc/ZX5V-7GWD>; Law Society of British Columbia, Notice to the Profession, “Anti-money Laundering Measures of the Law Society – new trust rule and cash rule changes” (15 July 2019), online: LSBC <www.lawsociety.bc.ca/about-us/news-and-publications/news/2019/anti-money-laundering-measures-of-the-law-society>, archived: <perma.cc/VG4M-6HYP>; Law Society of Saskatchewan, “Law Society amends Rules to help prevent money laundering” (last modified 14 January 2020), online: Legal Sourcery <lsslib.wpcomstaging.com/2019/12/04/law-society-amends-rules-to-help-prevent-money-laundering>, archived: <perma.cc/YQ4J-JZT7>; Law Society of Saskatchewan, Code of Professional Conduct, Regina: LSS, 2019, ch 3.2-7; Law Society of Saskatchewan, Rules, Regina: LSS, 2020, rr 1503, 1511, 1541–1550.

[9]           Attorney General of British Columbia, Dirty Money Part 2: Turning the Tide—An Independent Review of Money Laundering in B.C. Real Estate, Luxury Vehicle Sales & Horse Racing, by Peter M German (Victoria: AGBC, 31 March 2019) at 159, online (pdf): <icclr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Dirty_Money_Report_Part_2.pdf?x30145>, archived: <perma.cc/G32F-V5XP>.

[10]         Ibid.

[11]         Ibid at 159–161.

[12]         Criminal Code, supra note 3, s 462.31(1) [emphasis added].

[13]         The term “designated offence” is defined broadly in the Criminal Code as:

(a) any offence that may be prosecuted as an indictable offence under this or any other Act of Parliament, other than an indictable offence prescribed by regulation, or

(b) a conspiracy or an attempt to commit, being an accessory after the fact in relation to, or any counselling in relation to, an offence referred to in paragraph (a).

(ibid, s 462.3(1)).

[14]         See e.g. Marc Montgomery, “Huge money-laundering operation in British Columbia alleged”, Radio Canada International  (18 January 2019), online: <http://www.rcinet.ca/en/2019/01/18/huge-money-laundering-operation-in-british-columbia-alleged>, archived: <https://perma.cc/42R7-ALC4>.

[15]         Criminal Code, supra note 3, s 462.31(2)(a).

Share this:
    

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Archives

Categories

Subscribe Now

Subscribe for the latest news from our blog "Legal Sourcery".


Submit News Post

Submission Guidelines

Online Tools

  • Search
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • LSS Initiatives
  • For Lawyers & Students
  • For the Public
  • Regulation
  • CPD

Subscribe Now

Subscribe for the latest news from our blog "Legal Sourcery".

Stay Connected

Twitter
Facebook
Linkedin

© 2023 Law Society of Saskatchewan. Website & Hosting by OmniOnline