Law Society of Saskatchewan
Find Legal AssistanceMember ProfileMember ResourcesContact
  • 0
    Cart
  • My Account
  • About Us
      • slider_1Latest News
      • Pride Month 2022
      • Court of Queen’s Bench Administrative Notice
      • New Judicial Appointments in the Province of Saskatchewan
      • News
        • Legal Sourcery
        • Podcast
        • ReSource
        • Videos
        • Benchers’ Digest
        • Case Mail
      • Mission and Values
      • Committees and Task Forces
      • Convocation
      • Benchers
        • Bencher Election 2018
        • Bencher Election 2021
      • Annual and Financial Reports
      • Contact Us
  • Initiatives
    • slider_1Initiatives
      The Law Society is seeking to identify legal service providers for new initiatives. This unique approach, the first of its kind in Canada, enables the Law Society to expand access to appropriately regulated legal services in a responsible and sustainable manner. The overall goal is to balance the need for enhanced access to legal services for underserved Saskatchewan citizens while ensuring public protection. For more information, click below. Consultation
      • Access to Justice
        • Future of Legal Services Initiative
        • Limited Scope Legal Services – Information for the Public
        • Limited Scope Legal Services – Information for Lawyers
      • Equity, Diversity and Inclusion
        • Equity Office
      • Legal Information
        • Legal Information Guidelines
        • Saskatchewan Access to Legal Information
      • Innovating Regulation
      • Truth and Reconciliation
        • Additional Resources
        • Notice to Day School Survivors
      • Saskatchewan Justicia Project
  • Regulation
    • slider_1Remote Executing Of Certain Documents And Remote Witnessing Of Wills By Electronic Means Legislation Now Permanent
      We are happy to announce that today, the Government of Saskatchewan repealed the temporary emergency regulations related to remote execution of certain documents and wills and replaced those regulations with permanent regulations allowing for remote execution of documents via electronic means (i.e. video calls) to continue long-term beyond the end of the public emergency period. Practice Directives
      • Definition of the Practice of Law and Unauthorized Practice of Law
      • Firm Regulation
        • Designated Representative (DR) Hub
      • Act, Code and Rules
        • The Legal Profession Act, 1990
        • Code of Professional Conduct and Amendments
        • Law Society Rules, Amendments and Practice Directives
        • Rules Concordance – Read More
      • Hearings, Decisions and Rulings
        • Pending Discipline Matters
        • Discipline Decisions
        • Conduct Review Database
        • Ethics Rulings Database
        • Pending Admissions and Education Matters
        • Admissions and Education Decisions
        • Disqualification and Reinstatement
      • Lawyers with Practice Conditions/Restrictions
      • Lawyer Trusteeships and Successors
      • Potential Complaint Outcomes
        • Ethics Committee
        • Competency Committee
        • Conduct Investigation Committee
  • Public
    • slider_1New Law Society Complaint Form
      The goal is to assist and encourage complainants to provide clear and concise descriptions of their concerns, and reduce confusion by removing technical terms that may not be fully understood by members of the general public (i.e.: “conflict of interest”). Complaint Form
      • Finding Legal Assistance
      • Find Legal Assistance Search Guidance
      • What to Expect From Your Lawyer
      • Looking For Lost Wills
      • Making a Complaint
        • Complaints Process
      • Common Client Concerns
        • Understanding Lawyers’ Fees
        • Quality of Service
        • Conflict of Interest
        • Confidentiality
        • Withdrawal
        • File Transfers
      • Common Client Concerns
        • Role of an Estate’s Lawyer
        • Role of Opposing Lawyer
        • Breach of Trust Conditions/Undertakings
        • Lawyer’s Conduct in Court
        • Lawyer’s Outside Interests
  • Lawyers and Students
    • hiring sign resizedCareer and Volunteer Opportunities
      • Becoming a Lawyer in Saskatchewan
        • Students-at-law
        • Transfer Lawyers
        • International Applicants
      • Becoming a Principal
      • Career And Volunteer Opportunities
        • Students Seeking Articles
      • Membership Services
      • Awards, Bursaries, Scholarships
      • Consultation
      • Locum Registry
      • Practice Advisor Program
      • Forms and Fees
        • Law Society Forms
        • Trust Account Forms
      • Western Conveyancing Protocol
        • Protocol for Saskatchewan
      • Practice Resources
        • General Resources
        • Queen’s Bench Rules
      • Health and Wellness
  • Legal Resources
  • CPD
    • slider_1Continuing Professional Development
      • CPD Activities
        • CPD Calendar of Activities
        • CPD On Demand (Subscription)
        • CPD Activity Application Form
        • Recorded Versions Shop
        • Study Group Resources
      • CPD Policy
        • Reporting CPD Hours
        • Eligible CPD Activities
        • Approved Providers
        • Remedial CPD Plan Information
        • FAQs
        • Transition to One-Year CPD Term
      • Contact Us
      • Volunteers
      • Presenter Section
  • Shop
Law Society of Saskatchewan Legal Research Friday Tip: Case Law Searching in WestlawNext – Have Your Cake and Eat it Too!

Friday Tip: Case Law Searching in WestlawNext – Have Your Cake and Eat it Too!

March 6, 2020
Photo by Will Echols on Unsplash

By Ken Fox, Research Librarian

The great thing about searching case law digests, as opposed to full-text judgments, is that your search terms are applied only to a brief summary of the decision, not a full account of the case details. You get fewer results, and they are of higher quality. Since the cases have been digested, I will refer to this as “eating our cake.”

The great thing about searching full-text case law is that you can be very picky about what combination of legal concepts and specific factual elements you want to include in your search, and still get some results, whereas with a digest search you might get none. Full-text searching allows you to zero in on that small pool of cases that have closely matching facts. Since we are searching undigested jurisprudence, let’s call this “having our cake.”

BUT what if you are researching a well-trodden legal topic, such as oral contracts, and want to zero in on a particular factual detail such as one of the contractors being deceased?

For the case law authorities on oral contracts, a good place to start would be The Canadian Abridgment, available as a “finding tool” in WestlawNext Canada’s LawSource package. If you are a Saskatchewan lawyer, you can access this service through the Member Resources page.

Navigate to the Canadian Abridgment Digests, and click on “CON Contracts.” Now look to the right side of the page, the search box that says “Search Abridgment Headings and Subheadings”

Then enter “oral contracts” in the search bar. The system takes you directly to your term nestled under the wings of its parent concepts:

Click on the heading, which will take you to a list of 240 digests.

The next step is locating cases within that pool of 240 that deal with the narrow issue of contract validity in the event of the death of a contractor. Let’s try using the “Search within results” box at the top of the left pane – enter the term “deceased,” and click on “Apply filters” –

There are only two results.

Are these the only two cases then? Likely not. So the next step might be to go back to the WestlawNext home page and try a “Federated” (full-text) search of case law. But, you know that there will be thousands of cases using the phrase “oral contract” – you really wanted to limit your search to that pool of cases that the legal editors have classified under the heading “Oral contracts.”

You despair, because you know there is no way you can have your cake AND eat it too. Well, what if I told you that there is?

A few months ago, Thomson Reuters added a feature to WestlawNext called “Browse Legal Topics.” Look for it on the home page among the “Finding Tools.”

Browse Legal Topics applies the same main system of headings as the Abridgment, but expands the taxonomy and range of document types to cover all areas of law (not just litigation).

Just as before, select “Contracts” and find your way through browsing or searching, to our same subsubsub-heading, “CON.III.1.g Oral contracts.” There are 239 cases, as well as (depending on the scope of your subscription) other types of documents.

Click on “Cases and decisions.” We appear to be right back where we were when using the Abridgment (less one case, possibly because the Abridgment is slightly more current).

At this point, you are asking me, Ken, why have you taken us down this same path again – we need cases on a particular factual matter, to search the whole cake, but we are back among the digests, where all the cake has been eaten.

But, has it?

Go ahead and type “deceased” into that “Search within results” again, and click “Apply filters.”

17 results!

Yes, when you use the “Browse Legal Topics” feature, you can take full advantage of the Abridgment taxonomy AND search the full text of the complete LawSource case law database.

Now, the astute researchers among you might point out that, for the present problem, I might have achieved similar results with a proximity search of the full-text database (e.g., adv: “oral contract”/s deceased). And some very wise person is no doubt muttering that Abridgment classification headings can be added as a filter to federated search results. Well done! Let’s keep it real, right?

But the truth is, I chose this scenario for convenience, and I urge you not to dismiss this tip as a cheap trick. By combining the old-world utility of digests and taxonomies with advanced modern searching technology, you can add multiple new powers to your legal sourcery arsenal, and should learn to use them.

Share this:
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Archives

Categories

Subscribe Now

Subscribe for the latest news from our blog "Legal Sourcery".

Submit News Post

Submission Guidelines

Archives

Categories

Online Tools

  • Search
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • LSS Initiatives
  • For Lawyers & Students
  • For the Public
  • Regulation
  • CPD

Subscribe Now

Subscribe for the latest news from our blog "Legal Sourcery".

Stay Connected

Twitter
Facebook
Linkedin

© 2022 Law Society of Saskatchewan. Website & Hosting by OmniOnline